Why are we having the same old debate about youth football?

Scottish football continues to sell young players (and their families) a pathway which could take them from academies to the first team but which for most will never be a reality. And this is not necessarily because there isn’t the talent in the grassroots game. It’s the financial reality that makes money ultimately more important than talent (albeit there is an obvious link between the two) that governs Scottish clubs’ behaviour. And that behaviour militates against young (Scottish) players.
In the first weekend of the new season in the Scottish Premiership only 28% of the starters were born in Scotland, with data presented to the clubs showing that Scottish players under the age of 21 made up just 4.1% of minutes played.
In comparison, in the Danish Superliga, a league of much the same size, the figure was 15.1%. That’s better, but still a stark contrast to similar-sized Norway where homegrown players made up 72% of the starting elevens on their opening weekend.
Norwegian League rules state that a club's full squad must include 16 homegrown players and a matchday squad can only have a maximum of nine foreign players. Eleven of the 15 players who played in Norway's 2-1 win over Brazil in the round of 16 at this year's World Cup were part of the NTS pathway from under-15 or under-16s.
At the meeting in St Andrews in September, the Scottish FA proposed quotas, as well as financial incentives, in an attempt to increase game time for young Scottish players. The governing body put forward three suggestions: two under-21 Scotland-eligible players to start in all Scottish Cup matches, and two under-21 Scotland-eligible players to start in all Premier Sports Cup matches, and clubs should field Scotland-eligible Under-21 players for an average of 60 minutes in each league game across all four SPFL divisions (6% of available minutes).
Two votes were to take place on the proposals. The first, on the issue of Scottish Cup rule adoption, should have happened in October at the SFA's AGM, but did not take place. The SFA now says it is expected to happen in mid-December. The second vote is due to take place at the SPFL's annual meeting this month. The SFU’s sources tell us that at least one big club is not minded to agree to the SPFL proposal. With an 11-1 voting structure to get change, that only needs one other club to disagree and the proposals will not go ahead.
We all know that too few young Scottish players are making the grade at elite level in Scotland so all these concerns I’ve outlined here are not new. In fact, the same issues have come up in four major reviews and in several recommendations since 2010.
This summer alone, Scotland under-16 internationals Kai Hutchison, Keir McMeekin and Boyd Fraser left Dundee United and Hearts for Everton, Manchester City and Nottingham Forest respectively. Two of Celtic's most highly-rated academy talents, Erskine Rennie and Dara Jakiemi, have also headed south, joining Fulham and Liverpool. St Johnstone, in recent years, have made more money selling talented teenagers to Arsenal and Fulham than they have made from any sales of established players. In the Saints’ case, only one of those lads had any time in a senior, competitive game, and even then it was about 15 minutes. Previously, top players such as Andrew Robertson, John McGinn, and Ryan Christie, have all had a significant grounding in the Scottish Premiership before moving on to greater things. Go further back and most English top flight teams were full of Scots who had made their mark in the old Scottish First Division (think Kenny Dalglish for starters).
Of course, the impact of this is felt in the national team. The disappointing group campaign at this summer's World Cup, was a kick in the teeth after we had returned to that tournament for the first time in decades. Sure, it was a significant achievement for the Scotland national team, but we don’t have the quality of player to take us any further at present. This is demonstrated by the fact that Scotland has slipped to 18th in UEFA's coefficient, with under-21 Scottish eligible players amassing 18,706 minutes in the top-flight last year, compared to 80,345 minutes in 2013. The rules requiring Scottish top-flight clubs to have three outfield players under 21 in their matchday squad of 18 were abolished in 2013-14…
The question now is whether the next generation can be developed. We should all be 100% behind Craig Mulholland and his vision for a better way ahead. The Tartan Army will not want to wait another 28 years.
Michael McEwan, Ops Team, the SFU




Comments