top of page

Andy's Sting In The Tale (14/11/26) "Doesn’t Need A Job Any More

Andy Smith
6d
9 min read

102 caps, about to set a new and deserved record and Good Enough in Any Generation.

Andy was never a ‘shirt-filler’ but the truth is he is a product of a broken system.

And disturbingly those who can do something about it don’t seem to be doing enough.

Apart from maybe more than rearranging the proverbial deck chairs.


We’re collectively now getting to the final pages of one of our very own Scottish Football ‘Rocky’ storys.

Looking back it’s straight from the Roy Rovers stable and is really all about the underdog fighting back


Our skinny Glasgow lad Proved Them All Wrong


Everyone finding a way through the football maze learns soon enough that sometimes/often personal hopes and dreams are dashed.

Loads of reasons, but we’ve all been dropped overlooked and I guess personally maligned.

In hindsight it can be positive and it’s actually a valuable part of a Lifelong Learning.


But being told you’re not wanted, anywhere, anytime is never nice to hear.

Football dreams and personal desires get vastly over-played and when cracked, broken, or even shattered damage and even break a lot of youngsters.

And because the world charges on relentlessly football does nothing to assuage the stark realities that personal expectations were probably just always too high and the game deep down doesn’t really care because it’s too busy.

Football is not well set up to help our constant cohorts of victims through the predictable pain.

The truth is it has already moved on and ignores the carnage.


But, a little research shows just how flawed the current inside football mentalities are and have been.

I’m amazed that nothing before has been done.

Actually, no I’m not.


It’s a Fact That Back-Doors Work


Ask Andy or Kenny?


Our two most capped internationalists were not the instant progressive successes that you might have expected.

Kids mature and flourish at their own rates, not just by the calendar.


Kenny Dalglish needed his own route through schools, other grass-roots, and then Cumbernauld Juniors.

Andy needed a different way forward.

The crux was Chris McCart telling him, aged 15, that he was not and never going to make it as a Celtic Player.

(To be fair to Chris, this was an annual numbers game,.

Celtic have too many kids constantly churning in and out, and the usual limitations which come back to resource and investment.

McCart should maybe have listened to his coach, John Gallagher, who could see the diamond that Robertson was.


When Andy learned that he wasn’t deemed ‘good enough’ to ‘make it’ at the club he supported as a kid, he wobbled, of course he did, but it wasn’t the end.

Wobbles were followed by personal resilience.

That starts within your DNA but can be taught and learned too.

Regrouping, somehow, Andy headed for local Queens Park, then far flung Dundee, Hull, and Liverpool.

At Queens Park we saw an early insight to the frustration of a part time youngster working three jobs including one at the SFA ticket office.


Life is Rubbish With No Money : Need a job


Chances came and Jackie McNamara at United became an influential back-door route.

I love the story that after the club had put Andy and two other youngsters into a Dundee flat the manager worried about what young lads were getting up to when not training.

He learned that when the training was over the three youngsters went to the local public park and played football.

More Roy of the Rovers stuff and a legend in the making.


Andy pushed the envelope because of inner drive.

He wanted it.

Along the way Scottish football’s new cap who memorably attacked with his first contact on the Warsaw Pitch, debuting at 19 was a harbinger.

Strachan gave him his first cap, and we got a leader, and inspiration to all kids on the ever greasy pole.

But is it a lesson that football has learnt from?

Don’t be stupid Mr Smith.

Most broken kids just fade away.

And clubs have progressively recruited ‘foreign’ mercenaries who the hard stats show are accelerating our progressive and collective decline.


And that is something that needs real thought because ‘Back Doors’ are more important than most people realise.


“Baled Out of a Shite Performance...”

... by a lucky penalty because Doak mis controlled the ball.


That was the social media headline from one fan about Andy’s 102nd cap match.


It wasn’t easy to watch.


Enough said


Sting in This Week’s Tale


1. Planned Boston Re-matrix is Wishful Thinking

2. Nae Class Reds

3. Treasure Hunting for Diamond Jocks

4. Skelped Bums for Jags

5. Ex Hamilton Star Ban Ended

6. Regulator `Getting Serious’

7. Andy’s Weekly Jahnnie Corner




1. Cash Cow or Rising Star With Question Marks to Prevent it Turning into a Dog.


OK, sorry for the economist-driven ‘summary’.

The Boston Matrix was a really insightful business categorisation of four categories of products spawning the words, ‘Rising Stars, Cash Cows, Question Marks/Problem Childs, and Dogs.


Anyway.

We were in Boston

We collectively had a good time and dutifully behaved like naughty children.

But no nastiness and it was indeed fun.

I can well understand the commercial benefits to New England and that they want more.


And I get the feeling that there was a genuine synergy but the commercial plans of creating a biannual ‘re-living’ in Boston ad-infinitum, has ‘Tedious’ and ‘Diminishing Interest’ written right through it like a stick of Blackpool rock.


We will always have other fish to fry with the ‘forever and relentless’ pressure of the four-yearly Euro’s, World Cup, The Nations League, and constant Uefa over-subscribed club football programming.


I guess this is all about money and milking the fans like the aforementioned ‘Cash Cow’.


2. Well Done Michael from Wallsend


You are a hero.

And you still have the fans, (and an amazing pay out guaranteed).


Carrick has acted with the utmost dignity right through a very badly handled series of United caused, knee-jerk mini-events. A deeply dysfunctional business who have forgotten and no longer care where they came from.

Man Utd have shown they simply have no class.

None.

A horrible situation shapeshifting out of control where an avaricious Tampa Organisation first reverse-funded a hostile takeover and step by step are raping the revenues.

The Glazers don’t actually give a toss about the game, the fans, or the cub’s very special place in British and World football.

When Avram , son of the scion Malcolm, spouted Nagumbi like, “The commercial power of this club is not dependant on footballing success”, he was so wrong because he didn’t factor in a long and barren timescale and the constant need to recruit new fans, who want trophies for their local, wherever that is bragging rights.

The erstwhile debt-free organisation now owes someone nearly £800M and funding it comes at a growing annual cost.


The club stopped paying shareholder dividends in 2022 and is in the throes of serious cost cutting and staff cuts.

I wish Pochettino well but if he is just there to ‘coach’, he has no chance.

A club rotten from the top down and an insight to the future.


3. Hackneyed Thinking on a Gray Day?


Heard today that Scotland are on the lookout for talent and considering Spurs Archie Gray, son of Andy and grandson of Frank. But born in Harrogate and capped at under 21 for England and indeed Scotland.

And we’re also tickling Hayden Hackney, from Everton whose mum is an Edinburghian.

I don’t mind plundering other countries superior youth development programmes McTominay-style, but wish we’d also be prioritising our own.

None of this is rocket science.

Just classic business framework, process, investment and constant management.



3 Constant Questions That Will Bring Change?

Where are we now?

Where do we want to get to?

How do we get there?

(Repeat).


There, that’s it sorted it for you all.


4. Petershill for Thrills and Rule Bending


I saw this week Thistle Ladies were deducted 3 points, and £6000, (£3000 held over) for ‘paying’ amateur players and telling a few mistruths.

Fair enough.

The rules help us all and someone there was being a bit naughty.


And at the same time I’d have banned the perpetrators from the Glasgow derbies sin die.

Maybe I’m becoming right wing?

No, just fed up with unfair and out of place entitlement.


5. Rubiales Suspension Es Finis a Hora


The ex-Hamilton player and famous TV kisser is now allowed to take up a job in football again.

During his time out of football, Rubiales has been involved in various business activities, although without much evident success.

He still tells anyone who will listen that he had Jenni’s permission and is innocent of all charges.

Like Russell, and others who are ‘more important’ than their victims.

He’s been doing stuff during his ban.


In January 2024, he moved into cryptocurrency by launching an NFT with South Korean company Moon Labs. The publicity material invited those who were against “extremism and radical feminism” to invest. Very few actually sold and the price soon plummeted.


He has written a book, ‘Matar a Rubiales’ (Kill Rubiales), published in November 2025.


When promoting it on Spanish tabloid TV show ‘El Chiringuito’, Rubiales said “I won’t apologise to Jenni Hermoso today because I asked her for permission to kiss her and she said ‘OK.”

I believe her, she didn’t.


In Madrid his book launch was interrupted when Rubiales’ uncle, Luis Ruben Rubiales, heckled him from the audience, called him shameless and threw eggs, before being marched out by security.

Big-egoed-Rubiales was recently asked if he would consider a return to football at any point.

“No federation, no club, no league, in any sport, grew like the Spanish federation when I was president,” he replied.`

Tosser.


6. Much Needed Control of the Monster


From North of the Wall we can see what the very expensive Independent Regulator does for free and this week he has made a positive step.


Did you know that 94% of clubs in their top 5 leagues lost money last year.

And total liabilities exceed assets at 60% of clubs.


That’s not sustainable in any business sphere.


In response, the IFA now mandates clubs in the English Football League (EFL) and National League will hold financial reserves in line with their assessed risk level to protect them against economic shocks.

The solution is to first hold a ‘rainy-day fund’, equivalent to one month’s wages, and to control operating losses.

The average losses are accumulating madness and in the Championship are currently £22million, £7.5m in League One, and £2.7m in League Two.

And the revelation that 32 of the 116 clubs, would not survive 30 days without extra owner-funding is disturbing.


Football is fundamentally a business but it doesn’t seem to know that.


7. What’s Jahnnie Up to This week.


Will there be a challenge from Arsene Venger for the Presidente Role?

Probably, but Jahnnie will see all comers off because he’s paying for votes and has what he sees as the power.


Will employing an illegal housekeeper in Miami cause a problem?

No King Donald will sort it for him.


Imagine Being Called a Dictator by Blatter?

The 90 year old’s words this week, “Fifa is suffering under Infantino’s Leadership, Infantino knows no borders, My choice would be Seb Coe, but it’s not important who runs against him, what is important is Infantino doesn’t get elected”


And the last words about his attempt to avoid his shenanigans over selling the World Cup to get into the public domain.

Fifa want desperately to block the disclosure of all documents.

But, New York judiciary disagree.

Now the Uefa lawyers have the upper hand in a disclosure fight.

As they say, a developing story.



Sting is: Andy’s Friday Night Blog

Unless it comes out on a Saturday like today because Murray my Pic Editor was in Glasgow for the game.

Hope you enjoy my wee blog.

If you do send it to your friends and if anyone wants to go on to the Friday night mailing let me know at


If you don’t then I’ll refund your subscription and put you into the free draw to win a £Million.

And in the meantime do your bit and join The Scottish Football Union and complete our survey.


Andy’s Album of the Week:

Rumer : Seasons of my Soul


I first heard this wonderful singer back in 2010 driving back to Embra from Inverness on a night time A9.

I was transfixed and converted to her classic, mostly self-penned ‘blue-eyed soft jazz’.

Here’s a wee confession.

Back in the day when it wasn’t cool to do so, I really liked Karen Carpenter’s voice, bought a couple of albums. and enjoyed a lot of their music and still do.

Rumer’s voice is up there with Karen’s but different, and on the surface this is a wonderful album with gentle tunes, except they aren’t.

Recorded in London, it caused a fuss around an unknown debut artist whose talent was making real waves, so much so that when Bacharach heard her he flew her out to California to play and sing for him on his piano, chez Burt.

And it was the start of a deep and fruitful joint collaboration process.

For a cold Edinburgh day, this is a gentle backdrop and ‘Slow’, ‘Am I Forgiven’ and her version of ‘The Goodbye Girl’ are just right.

Comments


bottom of page