Young Sportswriter of the Year: and the Winner is...

We are delighted to say that we got over 30 entries from universities across Scotland for this competition. Thanks are due to News UK Scotland, the publishers of The Times and Sunday Times Scotland and The Scottish Sun, for their support and encouragement. It's always good to see aspiring young journalists coming through the ranks and there were five entries we deemed good enough to be published here on our website. We'll publish the four runners-up first, followed by the winner. Here's the winner, Alfie Robinson, from City of Glasgow College.

Roger Hannah, Sports Editor, The Scottish Sun, Alfie Robinson, David McKinney, City of Glasgow College

Scotland’s Missed Goals: How Inclusion Could Be Football’s Greatest Win

Inclusion, integrity, progressive. These are the words often used to highlight Scotland’s supposed moral distance from its southern neighbour, a nation priding itself on social conscience, from climate policy to public services. And yet, nowhere is this self-image more clearly contradicted than in Scottish football.

That this nation, so proud of egalitarian values, has failed so markedly to extend them to its national sport is more than ironic - it’s shameful. The first ethnic minority player to don the Scotland shirt was Andrew Watson in 1881. Over a century later, the list of successors remains painfully short. Che Adams and Nigel Quashie are often named as signs of progress, but neither was born or developed in Scotland. Their inclusion only highlights the problem, Scottish football isn’t producing these players through its own system, and often when there is an example the players are borrowed.

Consider this: across the top four divisions in Scotland, roughly 1,200 professional footballers are registered. Of those, only seven or eight come from ethnic minority backgrounds - a staggeringly low 0.6%. This figure is wildly out of sync with the demographics of modern Scotland, particularly in urban hubs like Glasgow and Edinburgh. Glasgow’s Pakistani community alone is four times larger than any other in the country. These are multicultural cities. Yet on the pitch, Scottish football remains monolithic.

Denmark, with a similar population and ethnic breakdown, currently boasts nine national players from minority backgrounds. Scotland? Still clinging to tokenism. As Rob Webb described in Holyrood, there’s a “fit in or **** off” mentality in Scottish football, both at grassroots and in boardrooms. For many young ethnic minority players, the dream of making it feels distant - not due to lack of talent, but lack of belonging.

That’s where people like Yusuf Bamba step in. As the founder of Scoutable FC, Bamba is doing the work that the SFA should have been doing years ago: creating a platform for talent that’s often overlooked.

“Scoutable has given a chance to players who’ve been overlooked by the system,” Bamba says. “These are talented young people who don’t always come through the usual routes - maybe because of where they’re from, who they know, or not having the right support system. We’ve created a space where their talent can actually be seen.”

Through showcase matches and trials, Scoutable has connected these players to real opportunities. But Bamba is under no illusions: grassroots change is not enough. “Real change needs to happen at a higher level, like the SFA or SPFL,” he explains. “In England, platforms like Scoutable get backing from the FA. In Scotland, we keep hearing ‘you’re doing a great job,’ but there’s no real help. Words don’t create change - support does.”

This lack of institutional buy-in isn’t limited to football’s governing bodies. Bamba recalls his attempts to secure sponsorship and media support with mixed success. “Some sponsors believed in what we were doing and were happy to contribute in the moment,” he says. “But when I pitched longer-term plans, it became more difficult. Even if they loved the idea in principle, they often pulled back with reasons why they couldn’t commit.”

As for media attention, Bamba acknowledges the exposure but questions the intent. “With the BBC, I felt the interest was driven by finding a story that fit their narrative at the time. I didn’t necessarily get the sense there was a long-term commitment to action.” He singles out broadcaster Jean Johansson as a rare exception - someone who followed up and genuinely tried to help. “Whether it was deeply heard or not, I can’t say,” Bamba adds, “but it hasn’t discouraged me. I’ll keep finding ways to make this issue heard.”

And the issue is continuously swept under the rug. Kevin Harper, who became the first black player to sign for Hibernian in the ’90s, recalls racial abuse without institutional support. “That was 30 years ago,” he said. “But I don’t think we’ve moved that far forward.” Today* , there isn't one black manager in Scottish football. Meanwhile, two white managers have faced public accusations of racism. The arithmetic speaks volumes.

Worse still is the silence from those in power. When approached by Holyrood a few years ago to comment on racism in the game, both the SFA and SPFL refused. The SFA offered a customary equality framework. The SPFL outsourced the inquiry to a PR firm. Neither engaged directly. As Jordan Allison of Show Racism the Red Card put it: “If there are no people of colour at the decision-making table, how can these organisations understand the lived experiences of those they’re excluding?”

Scotland's recent World Cup qualifying success may paper over the cracks and validate naysayers. Maybe. However, one can only wonder that if Scottish football looked like Scotland itself, we wouldn’t have had to wait nearly three decades.

*this was the case at time of writing. Now, Marvin Bartley is manager at Livingston.